Back
Writing Lesson: Paragraph Breaks and Supporting Statements

Writing · Lesson 60

Paragraph Breaks and Supporting Statements

Splitting an essay by main idea · choosing evidence · 8-question timed quiz · Bilingual (English / Español)

Show / Mostrar:

The essay · “Books Versus Movies,” by Julia (two questions use this essay)

(1) Most people probably think that kids my age like movies better than books because movies are not as challenging. (2) However, I think movies are just as challenging as books if you pay attention. (3) For example, the camera angles and lighting can give you clues about the mood of the movie. (4) Depending on the type of angles and lighting used, the mood can seem dangerous or optimistic. (5) So in a movie you can interpret what you see, just like you interpret what you read in books. (6) Movies are more social than books, because they are easier to talk about. (7) I hardly ever read the same books as my friends at the same time, but we go to movies all the time together. (8) Afterward, we can talk about the movie and sometimes make it relate to discussions in our English class. (9) Movies can encourage socializing between people.
English

The two answers: (1) Julia should start the second paragraph with sentence 6. (2) The statement that best supports sentence 2 is “As with books, movies can be difficult because you have to make use of clues to figure out what characters are like.”

Español

Las dos respuestas: (1) Julia debe empezar el segundo párrafo con la oración 6. (2) La afirmación que mejor apoya la oración 2 es “As with books, movies can be difficult because you have to make use of clues to figure out what characters are like.” (Como con los libros, las películas pueden ser difíciles porque hay que usar pistas para entender cómo son los personajes.)

Question 1 · Where does the second paragraph start?

Julia’s teacher says that there are two main ideas in Julia’s essay and recommends that Julia break her essay into two paragraphs, one paragraph for each main idea. Where should Julia start the second paragraph?

AStarting with sentence 2
BStarting with sentence 5
CStarting with sentence 6
DStarting with sentence 7
English

A new paragraph begins when the writing moves to a new main idea. Sentences 1 to 5 are all about one idea: movies are as challenging as books (challenging, clues, mood, interpret). Then sentence 6 changes the subject: movies are more social than books. Sentences 6 to 9 stay on that idea (social, talk, together, socializing).

A would put only sentence 1 in the first paragraph. B would cut off sentence 5, which finishes the first idea (“just like you interpret what you read in books”). D would leave sentence 6, the one that introduces the second idea, in the first paragraph.

Español

Un nuevo párrafo empieza cuando el texto pasa a una nueva idea principal. Las oraciones 1 a 5 tratan de una sola idea: las películas son tan difíciles como los libros (challenging, clues, mood, interpret). Luego la oración 6 cambia de tema: las películas son más sociales que los libros. Las oraciones 6 a 9 se quedan en esa idea (social, talk, together, socializing).

A dejaría solo la oración 1 en el primer párrafo. B cortaría la oración 5, que cierra la primera idea (“just like you interpret what you read in books”). D dejaría la oración 6, la que presenta la segunda idea, en el primer párrafo.

Question 2 · Which statement supports sentence 2?

Julia’s teacher also suggests that Julia make her essay more persuasive by adding statements that further support the point she makes in sentence 2. Which statement would best support the point in sentence 2?

Sentence 2: “However, I think movies are just as challenging as books if you pay attention.”

AKids my age actually like books better than movies because books can give you a more complete picture of a topic.
BBooks that have a high vocabulary level aren’t fun to read because you have to keep looking words up in the dictionary.
CAs with books, movies can be difficult because you have to make use of clues to figure out what characters are like.
DKids who don’t understand movies just like to talk about their favorite stars and action sequences.
English

A supporting statement has to back up the same point. Julia’s point is that movies take thinking, as books do. Choice C gives a new reason for it: movies make you use clues to understand characters, just like books.

A argues the opposite (kids like books better). B is about books being boring, not about movies being challenging. D is about movies, but it describes kids who don’t think about them, which does not show that movies are challenging.

Español

Una afirmación de apoyo tiene que respaldar el mismo punto. El punto de Julia es que las películas requieren pensar, igual que los libros. La opción C da una razón nueva: las películas te obligan a usar pistas para entender a los personajes, igual que los libros.

A argumenta lo contrario (a los jóvenes les gustan más los libros). B trata de que los libros son aburridos, no de que las películas sean difíciles. D trata de películas, pero describe a jóvenes que no piensan en ellas, lo cual no muestra que las películas sean difíciles.

Same topic is not the same point. Choice D mentions movies, and choice B mentions difficulty. But only C connects movies and mental effort, the two parts of sentence 2.

El mismo tema no es el mismo punto. La opción D menciona películas y la opción B menciona dificultad. Pero solo C conecta películas y esfuerzo mental, las dos partes de la oración 2.

How to work these questions

   Step 1  Read the whole essay and name each idea in a few words.

           sentences 1–5   movies are challenging
           sentences 6–9   movies are social

   Step 2  Find where the idea changes. That sentence starts paragraph 2.

           sentence 6   “Movies are more social than books…”

   Step 3  For support, restate the claim you must back up.

           movies take thinking, as books do

   Step 4  Pick the statement that gives a reason for that claim.

           clues to understand characters  (not books better, not boring books, not stars)

Helping a student with this

Name each ideaWrite a three-word label beside each sentence. Where the label changes, a new paragraph starts.
Check the first wordHowever and For example stay in the paragraph. A fresh topic starts a new one.
Back up the claimAsk: does this prove the claim, or just mention the topic?
English

Spanish writers also group sentences by idea in a párrafo, so the skill transfers. Use the Spanish linking words students already know: sin embargo (however), por ejemplo (for example), así que (so). They show that a sentence belongs inside a paragraph, not at the start of a new one.

Point out the false friend feeling in challenging: it means difícil, exigente (hard, demanding), not “a challenge to fight.” Sentence 2 says movies are just as demanding as books.

Español

Los escritores en español también agrupan las oraciones por idea en un párrafo, así que la destreza se transfiere. Usa las palabras de enlace que los estudiantes ya conocen: sin embargo (however), por ejemplo (for example), así que (so). Muestran que una oración pertenece dentro de un párrafo, no al inicio de uno nuevo.

Señala el sentido de challenging: significa difícil, exigente, no “un reto para pelear.” La oración 2 dice que las películas son tan exigentes como los libros.

8 questions · 10 minutes

8 preguntas · 10 minutos
The clock starts when you press the button. / El reloj empieza al presionar el botón.

Paragraph and evidence strategy · Estrategia de párrafos y evidencia

Show / Mostrar:

1. One paragraph, one main idea · Un párrafo, una idea principal

English

A paragraph is a group of sentences about one main idea. When the idea changes, the paragraph changes. If the teacher says there are two main ideas, there should be one break.

Español

Un párrafo es un grupo de oraciones sobre una idea principal. Cuando la idea cambia, cambia el párrafo. Si el maestro dice que hay dos ideas principales, debe haber un solo corte.

2. Name each idea · Ponle nombre a cada idea

English

Next to each sentence write a short label: challenging, challenging, clues, mood, interpret, then social, friends, talk, socializing. The labels change at sentence 6, so a new paragraph starts there.

Español

Junto a cada oración escribe una etiqueta corta: challenging, challenging, clues, mood, interpret, luego social, friends, talk, socializing. Las etiquetas cambian en la oración 6, así que ahí empieza un nuevo párrafo.

3. Linking words stay inside · Las palabras de enlace se quedan dentro

English

Words like However, For example, So, Also, Afterward link sentences inside one idea. They do not by themselves start a new paragraph. Sentence 2 starts with However, but it still continues the first idea (it is Julia’s answer to sentence 1).

Look at the topic of the sentence, not just its first word.

Español

Palabras como However, For example, So, Also, Afterward enlazan oraciones dentro de una misma idea. Por sí solas no inician un nuevo párrafo. La oración 2 empieza con However, pero sigue la primera idea (es la respuesta de Julia a la oración 1).

Mira el tema de la oración, no solo su primera palabra.

4. Supporting means the same point · Apoyar significa el mismo punto

English

First restate the point in your own words (“movies take thinking”). A statement supports it only if it gives a reason, example, or fact for that exact point.

Wrong choices usually: argue the opposite, talk about a different topic, or mention the right topic but say nothing about the point.

Español

Primero reformula el punto con tus palabras (“las películas requieren pensar”). Una afirmación lo apoya solo si da una razón, ejemplo o dato para ese punto exacto.

Las opciones incorrectas suelen: argumentar lo contrario, hablar de un tema distinto, o mencionar el tema correcto pero no decir nada sobre el punto.

5. Test with “because” · Prueba con “because”

English

Join the claim and the choice with because: “Movies are just as challenging as books because you have to use clues to figure out what characters are like.” It makes sense. With choice A (“because kids like books better”) it does not.

Español

Une la afirmación y la opción con because (porque): “Las películas son tan difíciles como los libros porque hay que usar pistas para entender cómo son los personajes.” Tiene sentido. Con la opción A (“porque a los jóvenes les gustan más los libros”) no lo tiene.

6. How to explain this to a student · Cómo explicárselo a un estudiante

English

Give the student two highlighters. Color sentences about challenge yellow and sentences about socializing blue. The place where yellow turns blue is the paragraph break. It takes under a minute.

For support questions, ask them to say the claim aloud, then read each choice and answer “does this prove it?” yes or no.

Español

Dale al estudiante dos resaltadores. Pinta de amarillo las oraciones sobre el desafío y de azul las que hablan de socializar. El lugar donde el amarillo se vuelve azul es el corte de párrafo. Toma menos de un minuto.

En las preguntas de apoyo, pídele que diga la afirmación en voz alta, lea cada opción y responda “¿esto lo prueba?” sí o no.

7. Pace yourself on a timed test · Administra el tiempo

English

Read the essay once, about 60 seconds. After that each question takes about 30 seconds.

Eight questions in ten minutes is 75 seconds each, so you have room to double-check.

Español

Lee el ensayo una vez, unos 60 segundos. Después cada pregunta toma unos 30 segundos.

Ocho preguntas en diez minutos son 75 segundos cada una, así que tienes espacio para revisar.

Palabras clave · Key words

EnglishEspañolEjemplo
paragraphpárrafosentences 1–5
main ideaidea principalmovies are social
essayensayoBooks Versus Movies
persuasivepersuasivomore convincing
supportapoyar / respaldarsupport the point
challengingdifícil, exigentenot as challenging
cluepistaclues about the mood
howeversin embargoHowever, I think…
for examplepor ejemploFor example, the camera…
afterwarddespués / luegoAfterward, we can talk
Try this next / Practica esto: Julia claims “Movies can be hard to follow.” Which supports it? (a) “Some movies jump back and forth in time, so viewers must pay close attention to follow the story.” (b) “Movie tickets cost too much.” The answer is (a). It gives a reason for the exact claim; (b) changes the topic to price.

Julia afirma “Movies can be hard to follow” (las películas pueden ser difíciles de seguir). ¿Cuál lo apoya? (a) “Algunas películas saltan en el tiempo, así que hay que prestar mucha atención para seguir la historia.” (b) “Las entradas de cine cuestan demasiado.” La respuesta es (a). Da una razón para la afirmación exacta; (b) cambia el tema al precio.
Writing lesson 60 · problems adapted from standardized-test practice items.
Insert math as
Block
Inline
Additional settings
Formula color
Text color
#333333
Type math using LaTeX
Preview
\({}\)
Nothing to preview
Insert